National margarita day is in February for some reason, but we're bringing it into the summer where it belongs. City Cast Boise’s resident margarita aficionado Evelyn Avitia taste tested a bunch of restaurants and bars for us.
Margarita Showdown: Where’s the Best Sip?
It’s national margarita day, and City Cast Boise producer Evelyn Avitia is taking it very seriously. She has your new guide for enjoying one of these icy cocktails. Whether you’re looking to get loose or grab a drink with a date, she’s guiding us through the most delicious sips around the Treasure Valley. Want some more Boise food and drink info? Head over to our Hey Boise newsletter where you’ll get a cheatsheet to the city every weekday morning. Interested in advertising with City Cast Boise? Find more info HERE . Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Coa de Jima
For dinner with your margarita, you want Coa de Jima. Evelyn had a pineapple variety, but honestly, you can’t go wrong with any of their flavors.
Bardenay
Even the non-Mexican restaurants are taking margaritas seriously these days. Evelyn calls Bardenay’s margarita one the most underrated in Boise, and she recommends the prickly pear.
Café Olé
Go on Wednesdays for a two-for-one special on margs after 4 p.m. Who needs to work on Thursday, anyway?
Casa Añejo
This downtown Caldwell spot is top-tier; it’s got a modern Mexican feel and they put a lot of preparation into their margaritas. It’s Evelyn’s absolute favorite, so check it out.
Matador
Try any of their fruity combinations (may I recommend the blackberry-habanero), or elevate your tequila expertise here. Plus, their happy hour goes 4 - 6 p.m. and 10 p.m. - close daily.
Hap Hap Lounge
This might not be the place you’d expect to find a good margarita, but the new and highly popular bar above the Treefort Music Hall has some great tequila and mezcal drinks to go with a solid margarita.

